The High Court gave reasons in a Road Accident Fund matter concerning an application for reasons after an ex tempore order that dismissed the action. The judgment records that the dispute concerned loss of earnings evidence, including expert reports and actuarial calculations, and that the matter was dismissed because the Defendant’s expert reports were not before court by affidavit or oral evidence.
It may be relevant to practitioners dealing with expert evidence and Rule 38 applications in RAF litigation.
Evidence from source
The Plaintiff was awarded an amount of R2 300 000 for general damages and a s17 (4) certificate for future medical expenses
Supports: The judgment concerns a Road Accident Fund damages matter and records earlier relief granted.
the issue of the loss of earnings and quantification thereof.
Supports: The dispute later addressed loss of earnings evidence.
The reports were not before court by way of evidence either orally or by way of affidavit. There was therefore no duty on the court to consider such reports.
Supports: The reasons explain why the court did not accept the Defendant’s expert reports and why the matter was dismissed.