The High Court heard an appeal about an order that stayed an application and sent a dispute under a professional indemnity insurance policy to a senior legal practitioner. The court held that the court a quo was not entitled to make that order on its own motion and set the judgment and order aside. The application was remitted for hearing de novo before a different judge.
This appears to concern how a contractual dispute-resolution clause may be handled in litigation and how a court may frame relief not sought by the parties.
Evidence from source
the court a quo was not entitled to make the order it made without deciding the issues the parties had raised and without hearing them on the order it proposed to make.
Supports: Summary sentence 2: the court held the order was not competent on its own motion
The application under case number 61050/2021 is remitted to the court a quo for hearing and determination de novo, on the same papers, on the opposed motion roll, before a different judge.
Supports: Summary sentence 3: the application was remitted for fresh hearing before a different judge