The High Court in Pretoria heard a claim for damages arising from an alleged assault by SAPS members during an incident at Mooiplaas on 11 August 2019. The Court found that the Plaintiff had established on a balance of probabilities that he was assaulted by members of SAPS and declared the assault unlawful. Quantum was postponed sine die and costs on the merits were awarded on the party-and-party scale.
This appears to concern police assault claims, vicarious liability, and the treatment of conflicting witness and medical evidence.
Evidence from source
I am accordingly satisfied that the Plaintiff’s version, insofar as it establishes that force was intentionally applied to him by members of SAPS, is more probable than the Defendant’s complete denial.
Supports: Supports the finding that the Court accepted the assault on the merits.
It is declared that the Plaintiff was unlawfully assaulted by members of the South African Police Service on 11 August 2019.
Supports: Supports the final order and date of the declared unlawful assault.
The determination of the quantum of the Plaintiff’s damages is postponed sine die.
Supports: Supports the statement that quantum was postponed.