The High Court considered a Rule 23(2) application to strike out parts of a plea in a dispute about payment for cranes and related equipment. The court dismissed the application and held that the challenged paragraphs were relevant to the pleaded defence and that prejudice had not been shown.
This may be relevant to civil litigation and pleading practice, particularly Rule 23(2) strike out applications and the distinction between relevance, prejudice and exception.
Evidence from source
In this interlocutory application, brought under Uniform Rule 23(2), the plaintiff seeks to strike out paragraphs 3.1 to 3.15 and 5.2 to 5.3.1 of the defendant's plea
Supports: Summary sentence 1: the case concerns a Rule 23(2) strike out application in a payment dispute about cranes and related equipment.
I conclude that the plaintiff has not shown that the impugned paragraphs, whether in the plea or in the proposed amended plea, are irrelevant.
Supports: Summary sentence 2: the court found the challenged paragraphs were relevant.
The plaintiff has not demonstrated any cognisable prejudice. That is an independent reason for dismissing the application.
Supports: Summary sentence 2: the application was dismissed because prejudice was not shown.